"It occurred to me, in California in June and in Atlanta in July and in New Orleans in August, in the course of watching first the California primary and then the Democratic and Republican national conventions, that it had not been by accident that the people with whom I had preferred to spend time in high school had, on the whole, hung out in gas stations." -- Joan Didion
Monday, February 27, 2012
First Look, Coming Soon
The First Circuit has numbered and docketed the appeal from Boston College, so it's now possible to start tracking the case through the courts. BC's docketing statement is due March 8, and will offer a basic first look at what the university's lawyers intend to argue, briefly explaining "the nature of proceeding and the relief sought." So far we've only had a spokesman's representations of what BC thinks their appeal is about.
Chris, the docketing statement is not really a significant event in the appeal. For comparison, take a look at the one McIntyre and Moloney filed in their appeal. Your first look at the substance of the arguments will come in the brief. But I don't think there's much lack of certainty about what the appeal will be about--BC will argue that the judge erred in his review of the second group of interviews because he ordered them turned over despite what he acknowledged was their limited relevance.
ReplyDeleteTed,
ReplyDeleteThanks -- I did call it a "basic first look," and it seems their description of "the nature of the relief sought" should give us a clue how far they hope to go with the appeal, e.g. killing the whole order or just pulling an interview or a few interviews out of the pile they have to turn over.
Theodore,
ReplyDeleteI notice you didn't comment on Chris' last post, "Called to Account". Any particular reason?
Ed,
ReplyDeleteJust that the bit about royalties seems tangential to the stuff I'm interested in--no other reason in particular!