Wednesday, February 8, 2012

Proof by Denial

Boston College did not clearly warn Belfast Project interviewees that it would not protect their interviews against a subpoena. Period. The explicit promise between BC and interviewees was simply that their interviews would be kept confidential until they died or chose to affirmatively waive confidentiality. The proof comes from campus, in the form of a statement claiming the opposite.

Along with this post about this story, I wrote to the editors of The Heights, the student-run newspaper at Boston College. I asked them about this claim in their story:
Though participants signed contracts that promised them privacy "to the extent that American law allows," project supervisors Ed Moloney, an Irish journalist, and Anthony McIntyre, a former IRA member, have been harshly critical of the University's stance in international media.
Here's the question I asked:
I would be curious to hear what evidence you have for the claim that "participants signed contracts that promised them privacy 'to the extent that American law allows.'" Did David Cote see the signed contracts between BC and its interviewees?
On Tuesday evening, I got a response from News Editor Taylour Kumpf. I respect the good faith that they showed with their effort to respond, but watch what the response does to their claim. This is the whole response, and read the second paragraph closely:
We realize that as the independent student newspaper of Boston College, it is our job to report the facts about events related to and involving our University, regardless of controversial material or items potentially damaging to the University's reputation. We also realize that as University Spokesman, Jack Dunn has Boston College's best interest in mind and is paid by the University to paint their actions in a positive light to the media, and this is something that we are always conscious of when speaking with him.

That being said, David Cote did see the contracts signed by Ed Moloney upon beginning the Belfast Project. Moloney's signature was on two separate contracts, the first of which directly stated that participants would be protected "to the extent that American law allows." The second agreement, which also had Moloney's signature and the signatures of project participants such as Brendan Hughes and Dolours Price, did not state that provision explicitly, but stated on Page 2 that the contract was governed by the provisions of the earlier contract signed by the project supervisor, Moloney. Regardless of what Mr. Dunn said about the contracts, Mr. Cote saw the contracts, in their entirety, with the signatures of Moloney and the project participants.

Thank you for your interest in the matter. If you have any additional questions or concerns that The Heights can address, please do not hesitate to contact us further.
So former members of illegal paramilitary organizations that engaged in armed struggle against the British government were given a contract that didn't mention that their interviews would be turned over to that government if it bothered to ask, but a clause on the second page of the contract between interviewees and Boston College incorporated, by reference, the language of a second contract that the interviewees did not sign and have not been proven to have even seen.

Does that description support the plain claim that interviewees "signed contracts that promised them privacy 'to the extent that American law allows,'" or does it show that interviewees signed a contract that did not make that promise in any clear or direct form that would have been recognized by the people reading it?

Everyone at Boston College knows the answer. An editor at The Heights, David Cote, personally saw a contract bearing "the signatures of project participants such as Brendan Hughes and Dolours Price." With regard to a limitation on confidentiality in the face of a subpoena, the contract "did not state that provision explicitly."

Full stop. The rest is a word game -- with the Irish Republican Army and the peace in Northern Ireland. Does that seem like a good idea to you?

Tuesday, February 7, 2012

Imagine a Rope, and Perceive It Around Your Wrists


From the same news story that I discussed yesterday:
"While Boston College clearly informed the project director that confidentiality could be guaranteed only to the extent that American law allows, [Moloney] and one of his interviewers have chosen to attack the University in the media for complying with the government subpoenas," the letter to students abroad read.
Language is a remarkable tool, and allows dishonest users to evade meaning as they appear to create it. The choice presented to Boston College was not simply complying with the subpoenas or not complying with the subpoenas.

Irish-American groups have attacked the subpoenas in the political arena, pointing out that those subpoenas serve a dangerous political effort rather than a conventional murder investigation. These groups have written to Secretary of State Hillary Clinton to ask that the State Department intercede and ask the Department of Justice to withdraw the subpoenas. They've met with members of Congress and asked them to do the same, and to contact Attorney General Eric Holder. They've secured the involvement of Senator John Kerry, the chairman of the Senate Foreign Relations Committee, who is also asking the State Department to intervene. They've met with officials at the Police Service of Northern Ireland to complain. They've done something. They've tried. They've bothered to be awake and alive, to speak and to think.

Meanwhile, Belfast Project researchers Ed Moloney and Anthony McIntyre have sued the attorney general, and have filed two legal appeals that have delayed the delivery of embargoed archival material to the police, an effort that adds time to the clock and allows for the possibility of political intervention against the subpoenas. Again, they've bothered to get out of bed. They've bothered to care and to try.

While all of those other people fought, Boston College laid like a lump on the ground, making a limp effort in the trial court before rolling over and going back to sleep. They've chosen a posture of helplessness, pointing at the rope draped loosely across their wrists and moaning that oh, what can we do, our hands are tied. Other options have always been available.

They have chosen. And their choice is shameful. It won't be forgotten.

Monday, February 6, 2012

This Is What I'm Talking About

Noting a growing "credibility gap," a U.S. Army officer writes candidly about the chasm between official statements about the American war in Afghanistan and the reality he has seen with his own eyes. Compare this piece to this one.

We all know this. We all know there's a massive gap between the things being described by government institutions (and other institutions) and the things that are happening. That's true of the economy, true of the wars, true of justice.

Our official and institutional culture is addicted to lies, and allergic to plain truth. And that's more destructive than anything any enemy could ever do to us.

The Heights of Credulity

The foundation of a successful career in mainstream journalism is the ability to assess a puddle of baffling horseshit and type it up as fact. A key to this performance is the choice of verbs: officials "explain" and "reveal," critics and dissidents "claim" and "allege." So there's some good news for Boston College: your student journalists are learning well, and will be eligible for post-collegiate employment in their field.

A Sunday story on the website of The Heights, the BC student newspaper, reports that the university has sent a warning to its students "studying abroad in Ireland and England," particularly in "sensitive areas such as Belfast." Not sure if they're putting Belfast in Ireland or England, there, but if they mean to place it in Ireland, let's take it as a political statement and suggest that Sinn Fein send them a thank you note. Our president thinks Tehran hosts an "English Embassy," so let's be kind on this point.

In any case, the warning is a stark one. BC's Office of International Programs -- joined by the chief of the campus police -- advises students to "avoid wearing clothing that overtly depicts American or Boston College logos during trips to sensitive areas such as Belfast."

Why is a Boston College connection something to avoid discussing in Belfast, just now? Why, because of those bastards Ed and Anthony, and watch this paragraph dance, dance, dance around a whole amazing set of obstacles:

"The Irish media has been heavily covering the subpoena of the Belfast Project, an international legal drama that could threaten the delicate peace in Northern Ireland. Though participants signed contracts that promised them privacy 'to the extent that American law allows,' project supervisors Ed Moloney, an Irish journalist, and Anthony McIntyre, a former IRA member, have been harshly critical of the University's stance in international media."

So the subpoena -- stick an "s" on the back of that last word, copy desk, so readers think you kind of know what you're talking about -- "could threaten the delicate peace in Northern Ireland." But the very thing that threatens to cause violence in Northern Ireland, the subpoena itself(*), presents no threat or difficulty to BC students in "sensitive areas such as Belfast." Instead, BC students abroad should be aware of the difficulties that may be presented to them by the fact that "Ed Moloney, an Irish journalist, and Anthony McIntyre, a former IRA member, have been harshly critical of the University's stance in international media."

The subpoena puts all of Northern Ireland at risk of violence; but only these two dudes mouthing off in the press puts BC students traveling in Northern Ireland at risk of violence. Nothing else. Just them. Those premises cannot be reconciled by sentient beings, but they occupy the same paragraph. Wake up when you type your stories -- it helps.

The warning to BC students also suggests that they "avoid political discussions regarding Northern Ireland in public settings such as restaurants and pubs," and that they specifically refuse to talk to anyone about the Belfast Project and the legal case involving the project's interview materials: "Do not feel compelled to discuss the matter with those who may raise it. This case is a complex legal issue further complicated by the politics and history of Northern Ireland, and it is best to simply decline to discuss it."

So BC students shouldn't display BC logos, identify themselves as BC students, discuss BC in public, or talk at all about local politics in Northern Ireland, because of BC's involvement in a "legal drama that could threaten the delicate peace in Northern Ireland." The institution that sent you to X location warns you that it is directly involved in an event that is so toxic and dangerous it could destroy the peace in X location, so for crying out loud keep your mouth shut in X location and don't let anyone know where you're from. Now, with all that in mind, watch these three amazing sequential paragraphs spool out in the same news story:

"The letter was our way of reminding students to follow common sense guidelines for an issue that is likely never to materialize," Dunn said.

The letter emphasized that the students studying abroad were not in danger, but that they should be aware of the difficult political situation in Ireland.

"Please know that we do not believe that you are at risk in any way, and that we fully expect that your semester abroad will be an exciting and rewarding experience," the letter read. "Our intention in writing is to alert you to an ongoing issue so that you will continue to use good judgment in all of your dealings overseas."

Warning! Warning! Warning! Don't tell anyone in Belfast you're from Boston College, and don't talk about politics, and we warn you! Warning! Warning! Warning! (Long pause.) Uh, don't take this as a warning, though. The peace in Northern Ireland is threatened, an event that is likely never to materialize.

This kind of bullshit-straddle has become a normal part of American institutional language: The makers of Gleemonex warn you not to use Gleemonex while pregnant, because the FDA requires us to inform you that your fetus may explode into flames. However, the makers of Gleemonex remind you that our legal department says Gleemonex has never been proven to cause fetuses to explode into flames. But just please oh please for the love of God please don't ever take it while you're pregnant, but it's not our fault.

In fact, this kind of bullshit-straddle has become so normal that you would think everyone can recognize it and perceive its purposes. But apparently not.

Finally, look at this part of the story again: "Though participants signed contracts that promised them privacy 'to the extent that American law allows,' project supervisors Ed Moloney, an Irish journalist, and Anthony McIntyre, a former IRA member, have been harshly critical of the University's stance in international media."

What evidence does the newspaper have for the statement that "participants signed contracts that promised them privacy 'to the extent that American law allows,'" and how do they present that evidence?

They don't, and they don't. Don't have it, don't describe it. It's a fact claim based on nothing, emerging from thin air. I've sent an email to the editors of The Heights asking if someone at the newspaper has seen the signed contracts with their own eyes, and I'll post their response if it comes. But here's my bet: If they had the contracts in hand, the sentence would include a reference to them. Instead we just get a claim that every interviewee signed a contract that included a warning about the limits of the law. Every former participant in a illegal armed paramilitary organization signed a piece of paper that said we'll give your interviews to the police if they ask, then sat down for candid interviews about their violent criminal past. Don't worry about evidence for that claim, because it just makes such good intuitive sense.

Boston College keeps lying because they keep getting away with it. I'm disgusted, and I understand the strategic calculation.

At least three times a week, now, I say the same thing about Goldman Sachs: If the country's political class is dumb enough to let you steal from them, then why not steal from them? If a drunk lets his wallet fall out of his pocket, is it your fault if you pick it up? (Yes, by the way, but I'm not talking about morality, here.) Apply that logic to Jack Dunn: If most people will let you lie to them....

-----

(*Actually subpoenas, but we're talking about the story at hand, and analyzing their framing. It's like fingernails on a blackboard, but still.)

Sunday, February 5, 2012

Fuck You, Jeff Novitzky

The U.S. Attorney for the Central District of California announced on Friday that no charges will be filed against Lance Armstrong, after a long federal investigation into doping allegations. ESPN reports that the investigation, led by FDA Special Agent Jeff Novitsky, "drew in dozens of witnesses, reams of scientific and financial documents, and multiple law enforcement agencies in the United States and overseas."

And what were they investigating? This:

"The Armstrong case had its genesis in doping allegations. But because sports doping is not in and of itself a federal crime, the case would have been built around fraud, conspiracy and other charges related to the violation of his team's contract with the U.S. Postal Service, which specifically prohibited doping."

Multiple government agencies just spent nearly two years investigating something that isn't a federal crime, bringing witnesses before a grand jury and trying to find ways to tangentially criminalize chickenshit.

Seriously, go fuck yourselves. If you can't find some real crimes to investigate, give up your paychecks and go home.

Saturday, February 4, 2012

Too Bad You're Missing It

I've been writing constantly about the Boston College subpoenas since early last summer, and two kinds of interest have sustained my attention. I'm interested in the case itself, in the specifics of the subpoenas and the particulars of the ongoing exchange between governments, researchers, and academic institutions.

But I'm also interested in the thing more generally, for what it broadly represents about the condition of our political and cultural institutions. (Hint: bad.) And it's been endlessly fascinating to compare what I know from court documents and conversations to what I see in the newspapers. My verdict on the news coverage has been pretty consistent: Are you fucking kidding me?

I'm reminded of the drunk in the stands behind me at Dodger Stadium who kept inviting the umpire to watch the game: "Great game on the field, asshole, too bad you're missing it." (It was funny the first seventy times.)

In the latest are-you-fucking-kidding-me development, the Irish Times reports that the Director of Public Prosecutions in Northern Ireland has given a speech calling for immediate and serious debate on how the North should deal with its painful history:

"Mr McGrory, who was involved in several high-profile cases during and after the Troubles, including representing the families of the three IRA members killed by the SAS in Gibraltar in 1988, acknowledged that tackling the legacy of the conflict was difficult. But he believed a proper debate was required as to whether there was an appropriate method that would be an alternative to the current situation where the Historical Enquiries Team and the office of the Police Ombudsman effectively dealt with the past."

Aside from the fact that the back half of that last sentence wanders away from its front -- it's important to find an alternative to something that effectively deals with something? -- any reader with the alertness of a geranium will quickly note what the story doesn't say: it contains no reference to the Boston College subpoenas and the ongoing quasi-investigation into the murder of Jean McConville.

So the police in Northern Ireland are investigating an IRA murder that took place in 1972, and the person who would be responsible for bringing charges into a courtroom as a result of that investigation says that hey, hold on a minute, let's find an alternative to what the police are doing about the past. And the report on the prosecutor's speech about finding alternatives to what the police are doing about the past doesn't mention what the police are doing about the past.

It's like (deep breath) the police are out in the streets arresting everyone who wears brown pants, and the head prosecutor stands in the public square and shouts that we shouldn't be going after people who wear brown pants, and the newspaper informs its readers that the prosecutor says we shouldn't be criminalizing the decision to wear brown pants, but the newspaper doesn't think to mention that the police are arresting people for wearing brown pants.

Actually, let me make that a little simpler: It's like the police are at least gesturing at preparing a criminal case against the people who killed Jean McConville, and the person who would be responsible for prosecuting that case all but says publicly, in a thinly veiled statement, that he doesn't think it would be a good idea to bring a criminal case against the people who killed Jean McConville. And the newspaper types up the text without noticing the subtext, which is all of a millimeter deep. Open question whether the reporters and editors who handled the story have opposable thumbs, yes?

But it gets so much better than that, because there's something else the Irish Times (and everybody else) didn't bother to notice, and let's go ahead and number these points to make them easy to follow:

1.) The woman who says she drove Jean McConville to her death says that Gerry Adams gave the order to take her and kill her.

2.) So an investigation into the murder of Jean McConville is an investigation into a crime involving the Sinn Fein leader Gerry Adams.

3.) Who used to be represented by a lawyer named Barra McCrory....

4.) ...who recently became the, yes, Director of Public Prosecutions in Northern Ireland. Maybe you've heard of the Director of Public Prosecutions in Northern Ireland -- he's the guy who just gave a speech saying he's not sure if the police should be digging into the past. Gerry Adams' former lawyer just dropped a fat goose egg of a hint that he doesn't think the police should be investigating Gerry Adams.

How do I know that Director of Public Prosecutions Barra McCrory used to be a lawyer in private practice who represented Gerry Adams? I read it in the Irish Times.

Two months ago.

Wednesday, February 1, 2012

Nope

Judge William Young has denied the government's request that he reconsider his "final order" in the matter of the Boston College subpoenas. A brief note on Pacer says that Young denied the motion as moot, which means he accepted BC's explanations regarding the remaining materials in the Belfast Project collection. Loyalist interviews are safe from surrender, for now. Note that the court has shown itself willing to listen to BC's representations regarding the contents of their archives.

And again: Why did BC fail to complete the same review of its interviews with IRA members, which would almost certainly have achieved the same effect of shielding most of that side of the collection from the eyes of the court? I hope that someone at BC will eventually bother to answer that question. In any event, today's decision leaves Thomas Hachey and Robert O'Neill naked in the light of day. I stand by this post.

Anyway, if BC is going to file an appeal, now's the time. I suspect they won't.

In other news, Belfast Project researchers Ed Moloney and Anthony McIntyre have appealed Young's decision to dismiss their lawsuit against Attorney General Eric Holder. The appeals court has consolidated that appeal with their earlier appeal of Young's decision to turn aside their request to intervene in the original court case over the subpoenas. Both appeals will be heard together in April.